I remain absolutely fascinated by the American cultural trend towards more and more passive entertainment.
On Friday, at the Justified/Stripped show, I noticed that the vast majority of the audience stood and watched the large video screens of people dancing to fantastic dance music. Rather than dance; rather than even watch dancers perform live on stage, these (mostly) young women were more comfortable staring at an enormous screen full of people dancing than actually DANCING themselves. It was their choice to watch people have fun, or have their own fun, and many of them chose the former. While me, a 9 year old girl, and a ragingly high gay boy strutted and sang and bumped butts and jumped around, most of the audience stood agape and watched the video screens.
The best was how, during the intermission between sets, everyone was milling around in the outer hallway area of Staples Center. Then, the stadium background music is replaced by a “THUMP THUMP THUMP!” The ocean of coifed, tanned, gorgeous people collectively gasped, split, and headed for the aisle entrances. I dallied, went to the bathroom (the line had disappeared!), and entered the arena to find that we were 5 minutes into a very loud, driving, artfully edited MTV advertisement playing on the huge overhead video screens. When it ended, the audience applauded, and waited another 10 for Justin Timberlake to come on. They applauded for an advertisement. Even worse, they applauded for an advertisement that had tricked them into running back to their seats to watch it.
Same thing happens at every Dance For Peace/Freedom/Drunkenness/Whatever. There’s a cluster of maybe 100 or 200 people dancing, and then a circle of people around them…just sort of watching. Rather than just get out there and shake it, get lost in it, get goofy with it, get whatever, they just want to watch people shake that shit.
If they think we look stupid, they don’t show it. They don’t point and laugh, they don’t throw tomatoes, or clap when things get crazy. They just stand blankly, arms slack at their sides, and watch. It’s kind of creepy, really. The only time I ever seem to interact with these people is when I accidentally get all “danger hoop” on their asses and accidentally toss a lethal flying plastic DEATH HOOP™ at someone’s head. Then it’s all “Oh! Oops. Ha ha. Thanks! Wahoo!” But that’s it.
What does it mean that people are so eager to live vicariously, and not live at all? Is it part of being numbed by our weird cultural empire? Are we opiate by our lifestyles? Or just tired from our 9-to-5s? I don’t know, but I wish everybody would get out there and grab their enjoyment by the balls. Or at least get out there and grab some stranger’s little dyed-pink dog. It’s the least you can do.
Hey there. I'm Ariel Meadow Stallings, a native Seattleite who's written my way up and down the Left Coast. Electrolicious is where I post daily randomata, but I also write for a living. My first book, Offbeat Bride, was published last year.
You're reading a page from the archives. Check the homepage for current content.
alison
June 22nd, 2003 at 11:15 pm
a few years ago i was one of the speakers at 20×2 at sxsw in austin. i did this two-minute presentation where i showed a video of me smoking a cigarette, and stood next to the video screen smoking a cigarette live. most people said that they looked at the video instead of me, and they weren’t sure why.
heidi janet
June 22nd, 2003 at 11:45 pm
i love that you brought this up. really. i believe that most of us are observers. it is the neverending cycle of leaders and followers, doers and watchers, fans and celebrities that define our culture.
i suspect the reasons may vary. perhaps some of us are crippled (wink wink) and are forced to watch. but i expect many, if not most, are too concerned what other people will think of them. how embarassingly uncool they might appear shaking their ass or clutching a pink dog. it never occurs to most people that almost no one thinks of them at all — let alone how uncool they might appear.
Cyn
June 23rd, 2003 at 3:24 am
Holy crap, I need a pink dog.
leblanc
June 23rd, 2003 at 9:55 am
the same thing was obvious yesterday at the Pacific Sound Sunset party - almost NO ONE was dancing - everyone was sitting in a semicircle just watching the DJs for a long time. vera and i finally grabbed our hoops and went out into the middle of the sea of sitting people and started hooping. most of the people didn’t seem interested in dancing at all - they just wanted to WATCH.
maybe it’s all the “reality tv” going on that’s turning everyone into obsessive voyeurs?
leblanc
June 23rd, 2003 at 9:59 am
that pink dog reminds me of the big white dog we had when i was little that we used to “color” every year with our easter egg dye after we were done dying the eggs. rainbow dog!
brodie
June 23rd, 2003 at 10:03 am
time to state the obvious. you went to a justin timberlake concert. as far as being trained to watch commercials, these people are like the ‘navy seals’ of television watching.
Ariel
June 23rd, 2003 at 10:07 am
What about these other examples, though, Brodie? Sure, the arena-pop crowd may be well trained, but they’re hardly alone.
That said, Amy (leblanc), I’m surprised to hear Sunset was a bunch of looky-loos. Back in my day (creak creak) Sunset was always packed with dancers and picnickers.
Echo
June 23rd, 2003 at 11:04 am
When I got the opportunities to visit Sunset back in ‘95/’96, they were all about dancing and conversing. I am shocked to hear that it no longer holds true? This makes me quite sad.
sarah
June 23rd, 2003 at 11:12 am
Our society has been well trained in the discipline of being passive….
I remember when I moved to California I was on 3rd street WATCHING this woman dancing to some amazing live music. I remember looking at how completely ALIVE she looked and feeling a pang of envy.
The only explanation that I can offer is that I just did not even think about the fact that I too, could have walked over and danced my ass off right beside her - and also feel alive.
She inspired me that free dancing alive woman….
I think in some way - those who feel free - help plant seeds in those who don’t….
Anna
June 23rd, 2003 at 2:41 pm
I blame television. The TV Cult is practiced in almost every home; compounded with the Marketing and Advertising Culture (bent on exposing us to product placement dozens of times a day) we’ve become a society of passive receptors.
Vera
June 23rd, 2003 at 2:46 pm
What a great article (the one from ‘97). Sure, it’s kind of obvious that you were a little more blinded by glowsticks then than you are now, but that doesn’t take away from its message. My favorite line: “It is imperative that not a single one of us forget our own power to be the star. If we forget, then we fall into the trap of buying someone else’s vision of our own dreams.”
leblanc
June 23rd, 2003 at 4:02 pm
Sunset wasn’t ALL observers. by the time we left there were a few dozen people dancing, but honestly most of them were just sitting down picnicing. and it wasn’t that hot either. i dunno. everyone seemed tired. i know i was.
Anita Rowland
June 23rd, 2003 at 9:10 pm
One of the reasons I like lindy hop — there are performance teams and competitions, but most of the time it’s just dancing without many people watching.
sean
June 23rd, 2003 at 9:28 pm
I would tend to put credence behind the “scared of what people will think of me if I dance/hoop/whatever” school. As someone who was constantly picked on from elementary school through high school (and even now in college, to an extent), I can tell you that, no matter how consciously you realize that most people really don’t care what you do, it still feels like everyone is watching you, waiting for you to do something stupid so they can laugh at you. I mean, hell, I even get self-conscious when I post comments here, just because I worry about what image I convey to everyone reading this.
But to get away from me for a moment, I think our culture has just become so hyper-critical and image-conscious that most people can’t help but go around with their primary thought being, “What can I do to avoid looking like an idiot?” So people don’t dance, don’t party, don’t do anything that they think could cause them to look foolish — even in situations where it really doesn’t matter what they do.
donut
June 24th, 2003 at 6:07 am
I have to agree with sean. I go to a mini-rave every week, and although I always plan to dance, I usually wind up just watching for most of the time. My problem is, the person I go with is afraid of looking stupid, so he absolutely refuses to dance. His fear is contagious… if I dance, I am aware of him watching me, and I know I don’t dance any better than he does, so if he’s ashamed, shouldn’t I be, too? And then I get all inhibited, and I can’t dance at all.
the mighty jimbo
June 24th, 2003 at 8:11 am
i’m surprised people actually GO to concerts anymore. that recliner at the house it far too comfortable.
we are a culture of fattened, disinterested, zombies with dead eyes, staring blankely at life as portrayed by disney or mtv, rather than getting out there and actually living it.
leblanc
June 24th, 2003 at 9:19 am
oh, that is so depressing. that’s why i love the “dance like no one’s watching” stickers that people hand out at events - because you should. i hope you guys find somewhere comfortable to dance someday (besides naked in your own living room, which is also fun); if not, perhaps someday we will throw a “Dance Like an Idiot” rave and you all will be invited
Maggie
June 27th, 2003 at 7:45 am
I’ll never forget the moment when my godmother “got it”…I took her to a rave (No-I-Tu-Love, for those who remember them) years ago and after just a few minutes on the side of the dancefloor, a light bulb suddenly went off for her and she exclaimed, “wow, you mean everyone just dances without paying much attention to other dancers??” and like that, she plunged in and danced her booty off. Gotta love it. That was the spirit!
kim
July 1st, 2003 at 10:51 am
i’m not sure it’s america-specific. i went to a club night in cologne and everyone was circled around the dancefloor not-dancing. this, a minimal tech-house night filled with 23+ people. they were all watching like some kind of middle school dance. it was freaky.
Katherine
June 22nd, 2004 at 8:23 am
yeah . . . I’ve been noticing that, too . . . and feeling a wierd sadness around it . . . I try to drag people out to dance or get them going (you mentioned you were once a Super-Rave-Cheerleader
but almost always they just smile sort of nervously and say no. Have you read up on un-schooling? I have a friend who is going to start home-un-schooling her eleven year old son because public school is zombifying him - he won’t make any sort of move without asking not only permission but the steps he needs to take and the order to take them in. This is a bright, creative, fabulous kid - it’s wacked. Schools teach a kind to be an efficient cog in the system - its no wonder people are too afraid to dance freestyle. And don’t even get me started on the evil feng shui of Wal-Mart 
Do something. - Electrolicious
October 11th, 2008 at 9:17 am
[...] written about this on electrolicious before, most recently in 2003, prompted by a Justin Timberlake concert of all things. I hate to sound like a broken record, but I [...]