Daily affirmations of a word mercenary
I’ve talked about my love of Social Psychology before, right? I’ll spare you the full dissertation, but the basic idea is this: as social creatures, we base many of our behavioral decisions on social cues. If you’re curious, you can read more over here.
Social psychology was a major aha moment for me in college because I realized that people determine how to treat you based in part on social cues you give them. Therefore, if you figure out what the cues are, you can influence how you’re treated.
When I was at the University of Washington, I looked like I was about 14 years old, and I wanted to impress people and be treated with respect, so I started giving people cues that that’s how they should act. It was sort of a “fake it until you make it” practice, where I would act like I was a competent, intelligent, assertive, articulate adult deserving of respect … and surprisingly, people took the cues and started treating me as though I actually was all those things At 20, this was a massive epiphany and akin to a religious experience. (Dorky, but true. Social Psych is more than an academic field — it’s a way of life!)
Ten years later, I’m starting to realize that there are costs to this technique of dealing with the world. In this last month of crisis and freak-out and sadness, it’s become clear that I am so good at acting competent and on top of it and having my shit together that even people who know me have a hard time telling when I’m feeling like shit. Even as I’m saying, “I’ve been a mess,” I’m still giving off all the cues that say “I’m fine. I’ve got my shit together on this one and I’m doing ok.” As always, people hear the words (”sad!”), but respond the cues (”fine!”).
Symptoms of this disconnect include people laughing when I’m telling a sad story because I have a pathetic tendency to make even sad things seem like LIKE SO MUCH FUN! because I’m so good at making everything sound FUN! Even when I tell people that I’m in a bad way, I still hear things like “I’m so glad to see you’re feeling better” by the time we say goodbye.
The moral of the story? I need to get better at having my cues and my reality line up. My fakery is confusing for everyone, especially me.
(All that said, I’m feeling a little better these days. But maybe I’m just lying again.)
Hey there. I'm Ariel Meadow Stallings, a native Seattleite who's written my way up and down the Left Coast. Electrolicious is where I post daily randomata, but I also write for a living. My first book, Offbeat Bride, was published last year.
You're reading a page from the archives. Check the homepage for current content.
Sarah
July 19th, 2007 at 7:42 pm
Holy cow, this is so my life. Put on a good show and no one will know what’s really going on. And yeah, sometimes is blows big time.
chasmyn
July 19th, 2007 at 8:47 pm
((HUG)) I’m sorry you’re going through such a difficult time. I really do hope that you ARE feeling better.
Tonya
July 20th, 2007 at 10:54 am
I’ve never possessed the ability to wallow in sadness in the comfort of people. One of my friends will cry to anyone who will listen when she has a problem and people put a lot of energy into comforting her. Sometimes, I’m a bit envious. Why can’t I let it all out? Why can’t I admit that it would be nice to have a shoulder to cry on? The answer is I don’t know how. I know how to listen and let people unload on me. I know how to fill the silence with superficial banter to avoid awkwardness for anyone else. I think I kinda know how ya feel. I majored in psych so I have neat defense mechanisms and I rely heavily on strategic misdirection. Both you and I know that it would take a long time to change such behaviors. I used to think bravery was putting on a tough face and never shedding tears or showing weakness and emotion. Now, I think it’s nothing more than cowardness. True bravery is being honest with yourself and letting people see your feelings, thoughts, and emotions with absolutley no shielding. I really hope you tend to yourself and allow others to tend to you. If you figure out how, fill us in.
Vera
July 20th, 2007 at 12:05 pm
Ariel, the question I would ask myself is this:
“What do I think will happen if I show weakness or even, gasp, admit failure?”
The answers might be stuff like
“I’m afraid that/I expect that:
-People will lose respect for me.
-People won’t love me as much.
-People will judge me.
-People will think I’m not fun.
-I don’t like myself when I’m not fun.”
But the real question is: Can you be absolutely sure that those answers are true?
helenjane
July 20th, 2007 at 2:42 pm
Hello, let’s have some tea together and be really, really sad for a while. And then we don’t have to worry about bumming those other folks out.
After this morning’s surprise tears, I realized, this is not going the way I expected.
Ariel v.
July 21st, 2007 at 8:25 am
OMG. I do this. My dear friend Amy does this. And then I sit and wonder why no one seems to want to help me. My technique is to tell my sob story and then have a great solution already boxed up and ready to tack on the end of the story. So I do share my troubles (as we are socialized to do, right, creates bonding?), I just don’t give my friends any chance to do anything to help me with them, like offer me a better solution, or offer their assistance with my solution.
I don’t want to give up my autonomy and my ability to take care of my own shit, but if I’m going to be like this I guess it’s also my job to recognize when I need help, and ask for it (like you have done recently). People love, and need, to help one another. I’ve definitely noticed that with my friend Amy sometimes I feel helpless and sort of neutered in my ability to be a good friend to her, b/c she’s so on top of things - and I want so much to be there for her. I think I probably do the same thing to my people.
So awesome to recognize this. Ain’t growing up fun?