Daily affirmations of a word mercenary
The other day, I got this question in a comment: “Do you find your fans/followers creepy? the ones you don’t know?”
The think the question was mostly meant in terms of Twitter, where the answer is most definitely no. I have two accounts: the one that’s private (it’s linked to my cell phone, and where I share Dodgeball-style updates about my location) and the new, public account that’s wide open and more a microblog. Granted, when I was at SXSW I was sharing my locations on that Twitter feed, but I was always with big groups of folks and never had any real concerns about being stalked.
So in terms of Twitter, the key for me is maintaining boundaries between the two separate accounts: the one for my “real life” folks, and the one for my internet friends/random strangers. (On this note: beloved internet friends, don’t be miffed if your follow request is denied for my private account.)
But to open the question to a larger context … the answer is a little bit more convoluted.
With the rare exception of the very few readers who slipped into abusive behavior, I find most of the folks who read my blog pretty much the bees knees. I’ve met some truly wonderful people through this website, people who’ve made the full transition to real life flesh and blood friends.
The only aspect that’s creepy is actually completely on my end: since this blog is not the full picture of me or my life, sometimes my “fans/followers” have impressions of me that aren’t fully accurate, and that can impact how they treat me … in ways that might not be creepy, but catch me off guard or piss me off. A few of these misconceptions include that I’m flighty because of the pink hair, childfree because I’m childless, stupid because I seem happy, not anal because I seem bohemian, carefree because I don’t often write about my difficulties, etc.
It’s not creepy that people have these misconceptions about me (because of course I’m the one withholding information), but when these misconceptions turn to delusions about my life somehow being better than theirs or somehow perfect … it definitely starts to feel weird.
Since I’ve done copywriting for 10 years now, I think that in some ways I inadvertently write this blog as though I’m selling myself and my lifestyle. I don’t mean to, but working in marketing for so long has subtly twisted all my writing to be persuasive. The result is that sometimes people mistake the nuanced manipulation of my words as the truth. If I manage to make my life sound interesting, sometimes people then think there’s something wrong with their lives; that somehow mine is better.
THAT gets creepy. And it’s happened several times.
When I get emails that are overly fawning or idolizing, I try to take the time to encourage the reader to come into their own power and awesomeness. I’ve said more than once, “Don’t go putting me upon a pedestal — unless you’re willing to get up on one yourself!” Sometimes this can be a great conversation starter … other times not so much.
I’m reminded of this great quote: Other people’s lives seem more interesting because they ain’t mine. I think that’s the only time I find any “creepiness” in people who read or follow my stuff. It’s only creepy when the reading of my life starts to interfere with people’s enjoyment of their own.
Hey there. I'm Ariel Meadow Stallings, a native Seattleite who's written my way up and down the Left Coast. Electrolicious is where I post daily randomata, but I also write for a living. My first book, Offbeat Bride, is in bookstores now.
You're reading a page from the archives. Check the homepage for current content.
robin
March 16th, 2008 at 9:34 am
Hi, random internet stranger here.
I follow your public twitter acct — none of my real-world friends use twitter, so in order not to stare at my own stale tweets all day, I have to find *someone* to follow!
Anyway, what you’re saying here reminds me of some wise words Anne Lamott once wrote: Don’t compare your insides to someone else’s outsides.
It’s an easy trap to fall into on the internet, because the journal-ish feel of blogs makes it seem like you are seeing other people’s insides. But of course, as you make clear, you are only seeing the outside, and for that matter, only the outside they want you to see.
Thanks for a great blog, it’s one of the few I still read!
Alison Headley
March 16th, 2008 at 10:54 am
“Don’t compare your insides to someone else’s outsides.”
Ha! Someone just told me that a few weeks ago, and I found it really significant.
Rachel
March 16th, 2008 at 1:06 pm
Another random internet stranger here… Enjoy your blog and thoughtful posts such as this one! I am still navigating the whole public/private contradiction that is living a life in the internet via blogs, flickr, twitter, facebook, etc. You seem to have done a great job finding balance. Cheers!
Nikki
March 16th, 2008 at 1:37 pm
I get the envy issue - I’m in the middle of a glorious Sunday afternoon, I spent the morning in bed with a lovely man, and now I’m headed to the pool to swim and then the bookstore to find something new and good to read. But, as I finish my glass of wine before I head out the door, I’m having a moment of pause, and I read about your trip. I would love to do some traveling this spring, but I can’t, so your trip gave me envy pangs, even in the middle of my perfect day. Human nature, American entitlement, weak character? Who knows.
Brodie
March 16th, 2008 at 8:39 pm
I think maybe the “wow- your life is nifty” thing as a way of saying…. you write well, you are interesting to read.
Ariel
March 16th, 2008 at 8:56 pm
Sure, Brodie. But that’s not what I’m talking about. Without getting into it, I’ve had folks take it way, WAY past that point.
Elli
March 17th, 2008 at 11:29 am
I also really like that quote–”Don’t compare your insides to someone else’s outsides.”
I know I’ve fallen prey to that kind of comparing on occasion, and it can be hard to remember that what people write on their blogs isn’t the whole picture. It’s a thin line, though, because I think it’s pretty normal to compare yourself and your life to others as a way to gauge how you’re doing in the world. On the other hand, it’s pretty easy to take it too far, especially when comparing insides to outsides…the gnarly mess of actually being someone to the shiny cover shot that everyone shows the world.
amy.leblanc
March 17th, 2008 at 4:20 pm
i have the same issues wiht some of my readers, specifically readers who have never met me/hung out IRL. they think my life is all parties and fashion shows. most don’t ever even absorb what i do for a day job, because i don’t write much about work. i think most especially weird is the visual aspect - obvi i only post FLATTERING pictures of myself, and i have a lot of readers who like to regularly comment on my appearance (men, mostly), and sometimes i just want to reply by sending them the most unflattering photo i can find as a counterpoint.
“Since I’ve done copywriting for 10 years now, I think that in some ways I inadvertently write this blog as though I’m selling myself and my lifestyle.”
on that subject and a little off this one, you HAVE to read this:
http://www.newyorker.com/ficti.....ion_kunzru
SolShine7
April 15th, 2008 at 10:35 am
Your last line says it nicely. You have a good take on the whole fan thing.
Bobbi
May 18th, 2008 at 10:20 am
I just came upon your site, yesterday. I have read a few posts and definitely enjoyed them.
amy put a link on her comment, to a post from the new yorker. Well, I just finished reading it and started to cut up some chicken and realized, I need to comment on this article. I started reading it and at first, I thought, this is not relevant to Ariel’s post, but it was interesting. I continued to read it, all 6 pages. It was interesting and I felt envious of the parties that were mentioned in the story, I wanted to attend such gatherings, why am I not like those people mentioned? How can I become them? Then, the story came to an end and that’s when I realized, it is totally relevant to your post. I felt envious of those people who turned out to be pretty ordinary or worse, the one guy had issues, far beyond anything I’ve ever experienced.
The moral of my ‘comment/story’ is; although I just read your post touching on the fact that you shouldn’t feel bad about who you are because of who you think someone else is and somehow their life is better. I went on to doing the exact same thing not 5 minutes later. Be happy for who you are, that’s my lesson for the day. I never realized I envied others until today, 10 minutes ago, so I guess it is human nature.
I hope others read your blog then read that article and can take away what I did. Thanks for making me realize that I have that misconception of other people’s lives and no matter what, I will never know who they really are. Because everyone, no matter how open they are about their selves, are their own editors. Thanks to amy for posting the link in her comment.